Amex Hotel Collection hotels in Islamorada

Islamorada has 4 Amex Hotel Collection (THC) hotels. With the Amex Platinum's $300 hotel credit on a prepaid 2-night stay, the lowest estimated cost is at Amara Cay Resort: 2 typical nights at $313 come to $626, or $326 after the credit.

Amara Cay Resort

Lowest cost after the credit

Amara Cay Resort

$326for 2 nights

2 脳 $313 = $626, minus the $300 hotel credit

Every Hotel Collection hotel in Islamorada

HotelAfter $300 credit
Amara Cay Resort

$313 typical night

8.2/10 (1,078) 路 $100 property credit

$326
Islander Resort

$507 typical night

8.7/10 (1,955) 路 $100 property credit

$714
Three Waters Resort and Marina, a Tribute Portfolio Resort

$549 typical night

9.0/10 (325) 路 $100 property credit

$798
Cheeca Lodge and Spa

$653 typical night

8.7/10 (1,168) 路 $100 property credit

$1,006

Typical night is the median nightly rate we track for the next 12 months, before taxes, as of November 2026. Estimates assume the credit is unused. Sign in on a hotel's page for its cheapest nights. See them on a map

How the $300 hotel credit works

  • The Hotel Collection needs a stay of at least 2 consecutive nights.
  • Gold, Platinum and Centurion cardholders get the Hotel Collection perks; only the Platinum's credit (up to $300 from January to June and $300 from July to December) pays for the room, on prepaid bookings through Amex Travel.
  • Breakfast isn't included, unlike Fine Hotels + Resorts.
  • Every stay includes a property credit of $100 or more and a room upgrade when available, on stays of 2 nights or more.

Frequently asked questions

What's the cheapest THC hotel in Islamorada?

By typical nightly price before taxes, the lowest-cost THC stays in Islamorada are Amara Cay Resort ($313 a night, $326 for 2 nights after the $300 hotel credit), Islander Resort ($507 a night, $714 for 2 nights after the $300 hotel credit) and Three Waters Resort and Marina, a Tribute Portfolio Resort ($549 a night, $798 for 2 nights after the $300 hotel credit). Prices change daily, so check the hotel's calendar before you book.

How does the $300 hotel credit work at Islamorada hotels?

The Hotel Collection needs a stay of at least 2 consecutive nights. Gold, Platinum and Centurion cardholders get the Hotel Collection perks; only the Platinum's credit (up to $300 from January to June and $300 from July to December) pays for the room, on prepaid bookings through Amex Travel. Breakfast isn't included, unlike Fine Hotels + Resorts.

What do THC hotels in Islamorada include?

Stays include a property credit of $100 or more and a room upgrade when available, on stays of 2 nights or more.

Other programs in Islamorada: All 4 hotels

THC hotels in other cities: New York 36 路 Washington, D.C. 16 路 Chicago 16 路 Nashville 16 路 Los Angeles 15 路 Austin 14 路 New Orleans 13 路 Las Vegas 12 路 Houston 12 路 San Diego 11 路 Boston 10 路 Scottsdale 10 路 Denver 10 路 San Francisco 9 路 Dallas 9 路 Seattle 9